Awareness

Here’s an argument that every respectable epistemologist will reject the conclusion of. But I wonder which premise most people will think is false.

  1. If S has a justified, true belief that _p_, then S is aware that _p_.
  2. If S is aware that _p_, then S knows that _p_
  3. So, if S has a justified, true belief that _p_, then S knows that _p_.

At a pinch, I’d say premise 2 is false. But I’d be interested to know which premise other people think is false.