I updated by reply to Patrick Greenough’s Mind article on vagueness. The current version owes quite a bit to conversations with Matti Eklund, and more than a bit to Cian Dorr‘s excellent paper Vagueness without Ignorance. I’m not sure I haven’t infringed on any copyrights between the amount I’ve borrowed from the two of them. Anyway, the paper makes a little more sense now than it did. The ‘arguments’ are at least arranged in some kind of order, in the previous draft they sort of fell on top of each other.