The journal survey is in the book. I’ve put the bulk of the data on the original survey page, but here’s some of the headline data. There were 175 votes – 181 submissions but 6 of these were ‘fill-ins’, people submitting votes for journals I added late or that they missed. Here’s the demographic data on the survey partipants.
Top 10 by average
- Philosophical Review
- Mind
- Noûs
- Journal of Philosophy
- Ethics
- Philosophy and Public Affairs
- Philosophy and Phenomenological Research
- Journal of Symbolic Logic
- Philosophy of Science
- Journal of Philosophical Logic
Note that 2 through 4 are basically tied – they differ by 0.01 points.
Top 10 by average (minimum 88 votes)
- Philosophical Review
- Mind
- Noûs
- Journal of Philosophy
- Ethics
- Philosophy and Phenomenological Research
- Australasian Journal of Philosophy
- Analysis
- Philosophical Studies
- Philosophical Quarterly
Most votes
- Journal of Philosophy
- Analysis
- Noûs
- Mind
- Australasian Journal of Philosophy
- Philosophical Review
- Philosophy and Phenomenological Research
- Philosophical Studies
- American Philosophical Quarterly
- Philosophical Quarterly
The demographic data probably give us a good guide to who’s reading this page, and are also important for interpreting the data.
UPDATE: I’ve posted the raw vote data for anyone who wants to do their own analysis. Note that each column is a vote. For some reason the table looks much better in IE than in Firebird, because of the odd way Firebird treats empty table cells.